< Back to blog
Trump at Podium
11/15/16 | Market Updates Personal Finance

What does President Trump mean for investors?

Now that the 2016 presidential election is over and we can refer to Donald Trump as President Trump, it’s time to examine some additional questions. More specifically, how will President Trump affect markets and other economic measurements? How will a Republican controlled Congress affect the economy? And what should an investor do?

Comparing the Presidents by Party

Princeton economists Alan Binder and Mark Watson made a detailed study, “Presidents and the Economy: A Forensic Investigation,” analyzing the economy’s performance under presidents of the different parties. Measuring economic data from 1947 through 2nd quarter, 2013, they concluded the following:

Democrats outperformed Republican presidents in terms of real GDP growth (4.35% to 2.54%)

Democrats outperformed Republican presidents in unemployment (5.6% under Dems vs. 6% under Reps),

Democrats outperformed Republicans in the stock market (8.1% for Dems vs. 2.7% for the GOP).

Despite this data, Binder – a prominent liberal economist by the way – concluded that the differential between Democratic and Republican performance is due mostly to “good luck.” 

“Democratic presidents have experienced, on average, better oil shocks than Republicans, a better legacy of (utilization-adjusted) productivity shocks, and more optimistic consumer expectations.”


What effect does the party controlling Congress have on the economy?

According to the Wall Street Journal, from 1948-2008, Republican-controlled Congresses averaged stock returns 7.1% higher than Democratic-controlled Congresses. Real GDP grew 3.7% during Republican congresses and 3.2% during Democratic ones.

The Immediate Impact

Global markets around the world are reacting with shock. Japan’s Nikkei tanked by 5.4%, most European stock markets are in negative territory and the Mexican currency has plummeted. And gold – often considered a safe haven in turbulent times – was up over 2%. The reasons for these large market movements are twofold.

First, the stock market simply had priced in a Clinton victory. One only needs to look at Monday’s almost 400-point market surge after the FBI cleared Clinton in the email investigation.

Second, the markets do not like uncertainty and there are a lot of unknowns to a Trump Administration. Remember, the markets had almost 30 years of “Clinton data” and generally knew what Clinton’s policies would look like – the same is just not known with a Trump presidency.

Please Remember One Thing – 
Past Performance Is No Guarantee 
of Future Results

The 2016 Presidential Election will forever be remembered as a historical repudiation of Washington’s political establishment. And it is precisely because of this that it’s important to examine the markets and investments of today vs. relying too much on historical trends or data.

Over the next few days, the markets will find their footing. They always do. Will the markets end the year in positive territory? Maybe, maybe not. Will 
the Fed raise short-term rates in December? Maybe, maybe not. Will unemployment and housing continue to be bright spots in the US economy? Maybe, 
maybe not.

Should you alter your investment portfolio because we now have a Republican president and likely a Republican-controlled Congress? No.

A president’s influence is large but still limited. Congress, world economies, foreign governments, military affairs, the Federal Reserve, and many other factors outside of a president’s control influence the stock market and the economy. And this time is no different.

The Most Important Lesson I’ve Learned

When events like the 2016 Presidential Election “surprise” the markets, I always ask myself what I’ve learned and how I can become better and more informed. And the answer to that question – for me – is obvious: the media was way off.

Up until Monday evening, I read poll after poll and article after article that predicted a Trump Presidency as nearly impossible. Even Fox News – a more right-leaning news outlet – seemed to have conceded to Clinton. How did almost every news outlet get it wrong?

Well, I’m not sure there is a single answer, but I have at least one idea. Specifically, I think that the decline in local media outlets has led to a consolidation of the “media” in New York and Washington DC. And the New York and DC media are incredibly out of touch with the rest of our country. This wasn’t a within-
the-margin-of-error event like Brexit (when polls suggested that England would remain part of the EU, but voters said otherwise). This was 1) either the “media” didn’t want to report true polling numbers, 2) the media is flat-out out of touch with the rest of the country or 3) they need a refresher in statistics. Whatever the reason, it will cause me to forever look at the media with a big fat grain of salt – especially when it comes to surveys and polls.

So What Should An Investor Do Now?

Nothing, unless your personal situation has somehow changed overnight. Trying to time the market is a fool’s game – you will likely sell when the market is rising and buy when the market is falling.

One of the most important things you can do, however, is to talk to your financial advisor, especially as we approach the end of the year.

Now more than ever, it’s important to make investment decisions based on your goals and your tolerance for risk. Not based on who sits in the Oval Office.


Copyright © 2016 RSW Publishing. All rights reserved.

Distributed by Financial Media Exchange.Material in this publication is original or from published sources, and it is believed to be accurate.  However, we do not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of such information and assume no liability for any resulting damages. All expressions of opinion reflect the author’s judgment at the date of publication and are subject to change without notice in reaction to changing market conditions. The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Midwest Capital Advisors, LLC. This material is provided for general informational purposes only, and it is not to be construed as investment or financial advice or an offer, solicitation, recommendation or endorsement of any particular security, product or service. Readers are cautioned to consult their own tax and investment professionals with regard to their specific situations.

Midwest Capital Advisors

​How political parties affect the markets and the economy

Now that the 2016 presidential election is over and we can refer to Donald Trump as President Trump, it’s time to examine some additional questions.

More MCA Insights

1/18/21 | Market Updates

As much of 2020 that fits on one page

S&P 500 Index Cumulative Total Return, Headlines, and Weekly Government Money Market Flows During 2020


bull and bear
3/20/20 | Market Updates Personal Finance

With volatility comes opportunity

With all the negative headlines and market volatility caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, I thought it would be timely to shed some light on what opportunities investors have right now. While there are a lot of things in this world that we cannot control ...


COVID-19 virus bear bull
3/11/20 | Market Updates

COVID-19 and the market

Financial markets do not like bad news, and the current COVID-19 outbreak is no exception. While many investors are tempted to “do something” in times of volatile markets, the best move for long-term investors is often no move at all.


Retired Couple
12/30/19 | Personal Finance

Secure Act 2020

​We find the majority of changes in the Secure Act to be positive, as the intent of this new law is to expand opportunities for individuals to increase their retirement savings.


Yogi Berra with quote
4/16/19 | Market Updates Personal Finance

Deja Vu All over Again

Investment fads are nothing new.

When selecting strategies for their portfolios, investors are often tempted to seek out the latest and greatest investment opportunities.


Jack GRBJ blog
10/16/18 | Personal Finance

How do I know who can get me to retirement?

There are a myriad of financial advisors with shingles out in every community and choosing the right one can be overwhelming.


4/12/18 | Personal Finance

Qualified Charitable Distributions Good Option for Those over 70 1/2

Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs) allow an IRA owner over the age of 70.5 to donate up to $100,000 annually to a charity tax-free. A QCD is removed from your total IRA distribution thereby moving your charitable contribution “above-the-line” from what would otherwise be a “below-the-line” deduction.


12/21/17 | Personal Finance

What does the Tax Cuts and Job Acts (TCJA) mean for you?

By Jack Nicklaus Tunge, CFP®, CRPC®

On December 15th, a House and Senate Conference Committee released a unified version of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. The bill passed the House by a vote of 227 to 203 and the Senate by a vote of 51-48 on December 19th. President Trump could sign the bill into law very soon but will most likely wait until January (find out why here). The following provides a brief overview of the changes that will affect individuals and, more likely than not, become law.


dollar garden
11/20/17 | Employee Benefits Personal Finance

Maximum Allowable Contributions 2018

The latest IRS information concerning Maximum Allowable Contributions (MAC) limits for calendar year 2018.


Retirement Just Ahead
9/6/17 | Personal Finance

Preparing for Retirement. Ever Wondered What a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ Does and How They Can Add Value?

​Midwest Capital Advisors’ own investment adviser representative, Jack Tunge CFP®, CRPC®, shares an example of how he adds value to his client relationships.


6/15/17 | Personal Finance

Big Wedding or Big Retirement?

Destination Wedding or Fully Funded Retirement?

Something to think about

Every year I am invited to 3 or 4 weddings and I love attending every one. But I’ve noticed a few trends lately and I thought I would put together some things for today’s couples to think about as they are about to tie the knot. Here is what I found:


Bear and Bull
3/14/17 | Personal Finance

March Madness and the Dow

Newspapers, radio, and TV news programs refer to the Dow Jones Industrial Average every day, calling it the Dow, sometimes the Dow Jones or even the DJIA. And economists and financial advisors pay close attention to its daily changes and the longer trends. But what exactly is the Dow Jones Industrial Average, does it really matter and can one see performance patterns from year to year?


HSA doctor and piggy bank
1/16/17 | Employee Benefits Personal Finance

Triple Tax Benefits of Health Savings Accounts

When planning for retirement, most Americans think mainly about using tax-advantaged savings vehicles like 401(k) or individual retirement accounts, while failing to consider the triple tax advantages associated with saving for future health care costs using a health savings account, or HSA.


portal screen
12/22/16 | Personal Finance

NEW Client Portal

We are pleased to announce a new technological enhancement for our wealth management clients.


10/24/16 | Market Updates

The Fed

Even casual observers of financial news know that “Fed watching” is a serious activity in the financial and business communities. Currently, Janet Yellen is Chair of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, commonly known as the “Fed.” An understanding of the establishment of the Fed, its basic operation and powers, and its relationship with the Federal government and the banking community is especially important at a time when the direction of the economy is under constant scrutiny.


8/29/16 | Employee Benefits

Investing in Your Vacation

Why do so many of us not use our vacation days? Salespeople talk about “leaving money on the table.” Well, employees leave vacation on the table. And the cost to us is significant.


7/28/16 |

Fiduciary Rule

You have probably read about the U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) new fiduciary rule that will impact financial advisors and their clients. Simply stated, the DOL’s new “fiduciary duty” standard requires financial professionals ...


7/21/16 | Personal Finance

10 Reasons to be Cheerful

Do you ever listen to the news and find yourself thinking that the world has gone to the dogs? The roll call of depressing headlines seems endless. But look beyond what the media calls news, and there also are a lot of things going right.


7/5/16 | Employee Benefits

Boosting Benefit Plans with Roth 401(k)s

As you may already know, offering a retirement savings plan can help your business attract and retain employees, while making it easier for you to save for your own retirement. To support these objectives, business owners may want to consider adding a Roth option to their 401(k) plans. As the name suggests, the Roth 401(k) incorporates elements of both traditional 401(k) plans and Roth IRAs.